View COBRAinReview in full detail. Visit COBRASolutions.com
May 2017

 

The Risk of Administrators Accepting Verbal Elections

In order to avoid the game of “who said what” the election notice should require the qualified beneficiary to complete and return the election form provided. This offers proof of their intent as well as documentation for whom they are electing. The following cases are examples of how risky it can be to use verbal elections:

Lackman v. Recovery Service of New Jersey Inc.

During the exit interview the qualified beneficiary, Lackman misunderstood the conversation regarding the coverage being offered when his employer stated it would extend coverage one month as a courtesy. Lackman then believed he would have extended coverage for two months.

When taken to court it was determined that the verbal conversation between Lackman and his employer was irrelevant as Lackman did indeed receive a COBRA election notice a few days after his termination. That notice informed him that he had 60 days from his termination date to make his election. The court ruled that this was a misstatement of the law as the election period is actually 60 days from the latter of the loss of coverage date, or the date that the notice is sent. In this case, that extra month of coverage that the employer offered him should have also extended his election period. Additionally, the notice did not include one very important element – the loss of coverage date.

Lloyd v. Harrington Benefit Services, Inc.

In this case, the qualified beneficiary, Lloyd, alleged he had been given a verbal agreement by his new employer to process and pay for his COBRA coverage from his former employer until he could obtain coverage under the new employer’s health care plan. Both Lloyd and the employer failed to send the COBRA election or payment to the former employer; however it was soon discovered that his coverage had mistakenly continued anyway when Lloyd ended up being rehired by the former employer. The plan was able to obtain reimbursement from the health care providers that had received the mistaken payments for $15,000 in medical claims incurred by Lloyds’ wife during his employment with the new employer. The health care provider’s then came after Lloyd, whereby Lloyd then sued the plan administrator for failing to follow through with the verbal agreement to take care of the election as promised.

The court ultimately dismissed the case because it was determined that he had received his COBRA election notice from his former employer and furthermore the plan administrator did not have any responsibility for the employee’s failure to elect and pay for COBRA coverage. The court determined that Lloyd was not entitled to COBRA coverage and rejected his argument that the other employer was obligated to pay for the claims because no election or payment was ever received.

In this author’s opinion, when an employer receives a verbal election, it would be prudent to make the acceptance of the verbal election conditioned upon receiving a written acceptance so that there are no misunderstandings and lack of documentation. In case the election period is nearby, request that the qualified beneficiary send an email or fax to be safe.

Working in Conjunction with Insurance Carriers

The following questions are examples of difficult situations that often arise between major insurers and employers along with possible solutions for a positive outcome:

What if the Insurer is denying COBRA?

First of all, the employer should confirm that the COBRA election notice was sent within the proper time frame. Keep in mind the COBRA statute states, “the employer of an employee under a plan must notify the plan administrator of a Qualifying Event with 30 days of the Qualifying Event.” Furthermore, the statute also requires the plan administrator to notify any qualified beneficiary, with respect to an event, within 14 days of the date on which the employer notifies the plan administrator of the date.

In the event that the employer failed to send the election notice within the proper time frame then the insurer can deny COBRA coverage. This means the employer will become self-insured for any and all claims made during the full 18, 29, or 36 month COBBRA coverage period. If confirmation can be made that the election notice was sent in a timely manner and everything was done correctly then the following steps should be taken:

a) Obtain the specific reason the insurer is denying coverage b) Provide documentation of your COBRA compliance along with applicable legal guidance. These can be found in either the notice regulations issued by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) in 2004, or the COBRA regulations issued by IRS in 1999 and 2001. c) Examine the COBRA language in the insurance contract and policy – specifically find the part that outlines what obligates the insurer to comply with COBRA.

What if the Insurer is denying an Extension of Coverage?

The first thing to do is make sure the qualified beneficiary was properly notified of their 60-day responsibility to notify the plan of a secondary event. The notice must include who should be notified and in what manner. Remember that until a qualified beneficiary has been notified the “clock does not start ticking.”

In order to ensure the extension will be accepted, the employer should first obtain the specific reason for the denial from the employer and then:

  1. Submit documentation proving the proper time frame was met
  2. Submit documentation received from the qualified beneficiary
  3. Provide the DOL’s 2004 final regulations.

In summary, timing is of the utmost importance when dealing with COBRA. In this author’s opinion employers must work in conjunction with insurance carriers to ensure all rules and regulations are followed. Otherwise, the employer will run the risk of becoming self-insured which could be potentially devastating financially.

 



In this Issue:

The Risk of Administrators Accepting Verbal Elections

Working in Conjunction with Insurance Carriers

See Also:

COBRA Solutions
Cafeteria Plan Manager
QSE HRA Manager
COBRA Administration Manager
U.S. Department of Labor
COBRA and the Trade Act of 2002
COBRA and Medicare Entitlement


Technical Information
The current version of COBRA Administration Manager (CAM) is 17.1.22.
For information on changes to CAM and technical assistance on updating the software, please review the links below.
COBRA Solutions - Support
What has changed in CAM?
How do I UPDATE CAM?
How do I REINSTALL CAM?
How do I BACKUP CAM?


Announcements:
Our customers can now earn $50 for each referral that leads to a new COBRA Solutions customer. This money can be applied against any COBRA Solutions product or support service invoice. If you know of another company that could benefit from using our software, let us know and it could earn you $50 for every referral you provide. This is a great way to reduce your costs and contribute to the ever-growing network of COBRA Solutions customers. Call us at 800-325-1957.

COPYRIGHT INFORMATION
COBRAinReview and its contents are copyrighted and are proprietary products of COBRA Solutions, Inc. Any unauthorized use, reproduction, or transfer of its contents, in any medium, is strictly prohibited.
COBRA Solution, Inc., 4500 S. Lakeshore Dr. #420, Tempe, Arizona 85282, USA